With close to twenty million rental properties in the US today, landlords are used to dealing with paint jobs, right? But if you’re a busy landlord, DIY painting can be hard to fit into your schedule. Leaving prospective tenants to paint for you can lead to quality and longevity issues.
And if you don’t keep a property in solid condition, tenants might paint it themselves — which can lead to issues with lease agreements, security deposits, and even disputes down the line.
These headaches are the bane of a landlord’s life, so how can you make rental property painting a little easier to deal with? This guide breaks down how to tackle it.
Rental Painting Tips From Property Management Professionals
Poor reviews. Unhappy tenants. Withheld payments. Legal disputes. Tenants who take it upon themselves to paint without written permission. Apartments that no longer match the original color, forcing you into an expensive repaint. These are the kind of problems that leave a landlord exasperated.
To avoid that headache, the property management experts at Utopia Property Management shared this advice. Use it to make painting your next rental house or apartment easier — and keep your tenants happy while you’re at it.
Should You Wait Until Your Tenant Moves Out?
Yes. Generally, it’s always better to carry out painting between tenants than during a tenancy. Here’s why:
- Waiting until a tenant moves out makes the job faster—you have fewer obstacles to work around.
- You reduce the risk of disturbing your tenants, which could infringe on their legal rights.
- With no tenants in the unit, you can air the property out, so paint dries faster.
- You don’t need to worry about liability for paint landing on tenant furniture.
While this often means a more comprehensive project – likely a full-scale repainting of the property – it ensures fewer obstacles and potential conflicts. Even with long-term tenants, it’s best to wait until their tenancy ends. Even if the ‘useful life’ of your paintwork expires, Utopia do not recommend mid-tenancy painting work.
Can You Skip Painting Between Tenancies?
Utopia experts recommend always painting in between tenancies. Even if you think the paint job looks good, carrying out a touch-up paint job is highly recommended. New tenants will spot an apartment that has not been recently painted: they’ll notice those little scuffs and fingerprints that you’d hoped they wouldn’t!
Painting between tenancies is a must: it helps the property feel as fresh as possible before a new tenancy agreement starts.
Set a Clear Painting Schedule
Most legal frameworks in the US give interior painting in rental properties a lifespan of around three to five years. Industry professionals call this the “economic useful lifespan”: once a paint job passes that window, it’s depreciated its economic value. In practice, that means you may not be able to charge tenants for repainting costs—even when there’s damage.
So it can often make sense to set a clear painting schedule. It keeps you within these regulatory frameworks, and it means you can charge tenants for repainting if they request it or it’s required before the three-to-five-year mark. Again, though, it’s usually best to leave any painting projects until you are between tenancies – even if the useful life has expired.
Focus On High Traffic Areas
Property management pros at Utopia Property Management recommend starting with a property’s high-traffic areas.
Ideally, property owners should give rooms like living rooms, kitchens, dining rooms, bathrooms, and halls a fresh coat every three to five years. Experts still recommend avoiding repaints during tenancies, however.
For less-used rooms — storage areas, laundry rooms, bedrooms — you can usually push maintenance to the five-year maximum. If you’re trying to limit what you invest in a rental property, focus on high-traffic areas first. That buys you more time to plan for labor costs without leaving the property looking neglected. That said, plan for a full repaint between tenancies as the ideal scenario.
Touch Up Access Points With New Paint
When painting walls and ceilings, it’s easy to forget access points like doors and windows. Make time to touch up the paint around door frames, windows, and window sills. Neglected frames — especially white ones — start to look dated and dull fast, so a quick touch-up here makes a bigger impact than you might expect.
Plan for Normal Wear and Tear Outside Your Maintenance Cycle
The three-to-five-year cycle is a good starting point, but the rental market changes quickly. Budget for painting costs from:
- Emergency tenancy turnover: if a tenant moves out, it’s good practice to freshen the property up before new tenants arrive.
- General wear and tear: minor scuffs, small nail holes, or sun-faded paint.
- Modernization projects: new appliance installations, energy upgrades, or similar work that often calls for repainting at the same time.
If tenants damage the property — large holes, major stains, smoke damage (especially where it’s prohibited by the tenancy agreement), or unauthorized painting without written permission — they’re on the hook for the repair costs. The same goes for an accidental paint job: if it’s not in writing, it’s not permitted!
Let the property fall outside the three-to-five-year cycle, though, and you’re more likely to end up liable for some or all of the costs yourself. High-turnover properties may also need more frequent touch-ups.
Skip the Accent Wall If You Can
Most property managers advise against accent walls in rental units. Keep the palette neutral instead. Here’s why:
- Accent walls can clash with a renter’s taste, inviting disputes or repaint requests—meaning you’ll need to restore the original color once they leave.
- An accent wall can also highlight scuffs, marks, and imperfections. If you do use one, stick to darker colors like navy blue to disguise marks.
- Minor accents, trim, and structural details do the same visual work with less risk — they let the property’s permanent aesthetic carry the room, not the paint.
- Neutral colors let a room’s natural light do the talking while making the space feel larger. Warm whites, soft grays, and muted beige are versatile choices that work in most scenarios.
- If you want to add color, keep it to warm, cozy shades — or subtle touches like light blue, green, or pink.
Rental properties should have wide appeal to attract as many prospective tenants as possible, so avoid anything that could deter one.
Use a Trusted Local Professional Painting Service
Finally, skip the DIY route. It might look like cost savings on paper, but — especially if you manage many rentals — you’ll spend more time painting each property than you planned for. And if the finish isn’t up to par, you may end up with more than minor scuffs or brush marks.
The main reason to consider hiring a professional painting service is simple: they’ll have a crew of dedicated painters who will get the job done faster and reduce vacancy time. Other benefits of hiring a professional painting service include:
- You’ll save money in the long run. A single room typically costs $200–600 to paint professionally, and a pro gets it right the first time.
- Professionals handle the prep work you might not have the time or tools for — thorough cleaning, sanding, and proper primer.
- Quality paint and tools mean fewer repaints. Proper prep and good paint can last 5 to 7 years.
- Fewer coats mean a faster job — which saves you both time and money.
- Low or zero-VOC paints are standard for most professionals, which means a healthier space for your tenants.
- A guarantee covers you. If problems come up, the painter handles the repairs — not you.
Lastly, when choosing a professional painting company, we recommend hiring a company that specializes in unit turnovers. They tend to handle rapid-fire, efficient painting better. Boutique painting companies generally leave a good finish, but they take twice as long, hurting your bottom line due to longer vacancies.
Keep Your Rental Property Painting Simple, Not Stressful
From saving time to keeping the job properly prepped and tenants satisfied with the result, hiring a professional painter is almost always the better call. Whether you’re repainting one room or the whole building floor to ceiling, the benefits outweigh whatever you’d save by doing it yourself.
Put these tips into practice and keep property management from becoming more taxing than it needs to be. Painting is easy to forget, but it makes a real difference to your property’s interior, exterior, and curb appeal—protecting your long-term ROI and giving everyone involved a better night’s sleep!